Temperature trends vary greatly across different parts of the globe, an aspect that is not recognized when homogenizing temperatures. At a top level NASA GISS usefully split their global temperature anomaly into eight bands of latitude. I have graphed the five year moving averages for each band, along with the Gistemp global anomaly in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Gistemp global temperature anomalies by band of latitude.
The biggest oddity is the 64S-90S band. This bottom slice of the globe roughly equates to Antarctica, which is South of 66°34′S. Not only was there massive cooling until 1930 – in contradiction to the global trend – but prior to the 1970 was very large volatility in temperatures, despite my using five year moving averages. Looking at the GHCN database of weather stations, there none listed in Antarctica until Rothera point started collecting data in 1946, as shown in Figure 21.
Figure 2. A selection of temperature anomalies in the Antarctica. The most numerous are either on the Antarctic Pennisula, or the islands just to the North.
The only long record is at Base Orcadas located at (60.8 S 44.7 W). I have graphed the GISS homogenised temperature anomaly data for station 701889680000 with the Gistemp 64S-90S band in Figure 3.
Figure 3. Gistemp 64S-90S annual temperature anomaly compared to Base Orcadas GISS homogenised data.
There is a remarkable similarity in the data sets until 1950, after which they appear unrelated. This suggests that in the absence of other data, Base Orcadas was the principle element in creating a proxy for the missing Antarctic data, despite it being located outside the area, and not being related to the actual data for well over half a century. The outcome is to bias the overall global temperature anomaly by suppressing the early twentieth century warming, making the late twentieth century warming appear relatively greater than is the underlying reality2. The error is due to assuming that temperature trends are the same at different latitudes are the same, an assumption that the homogenised data shows to be false.
- Also in Antarctica (but not listed) there has been data collected at Amundsen-Scot base at the South Pole (90.0 S 0.0 E) since 1957, and at Vostok base (78.5 S 106.9 E) since 1958.
Removing the Antarctic data would increase both the early twentieth century and post 1975 warming periods. But, given that 64S-90S is 5% of the global surface area, I estimate it would increase the earlier warming trends by 5-10% as against 1-3% for the later trend.